1812 S Osprey Avenue, Sarasota, FL 34239
1812 S Osprey Avenue, Sarasota, FL 34239
Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Menus

View Menu PDF

Starters

  • Island Charcuterie Board (for 2)

    Assorted Reef Cakes | Chilled Gulf Shrimp | Assorted Boar’s Head Meats and Cheese | House-Smoked Salmon Deviled Eggs | Various Tasty Bites

    $45

  • Reef Cakes’ Slider Quatro

    Asian-Style Salmon Reef Cake with Asian Red Cabbage Slaw | Cajun Snapper and Shrimp Reef Cake with Caribbean Salsa | Maryland-style Jumbo Lump Crab Reef Cake with Key Lime Tartar Sauce | Jamaican Jerk Grouper Reef Cake with Jerk Sauce | Served on Slider Buns

    $29

  • Rank’n Dan

    Spicy Fresh-Ground Beef Quesadilla | Pico de Gallo | Sautéed Peppers and Onions | Cilantro Avocado Crema | Cold Red Stripe Beer

    $25

  • Adult Fish Sticks

    Breaded and Baked Cold Water Cod Loins | Asian Red Cabbage Slaw | Key Lime Tartar Sauce

    $16

  • Shrimp Cocktail

    Chilled Gulf Shrimp | Cocktail Sauce | Lemon

    $18

  • House-Smoked Salmon Deviled Eggs

    $14

  • Teriyaki Salmon Bites

    Mini Asian-Style Salmon Reef Cakes | Teriyaki Sauce

    $16

  • El Jefe

    Roasted Taders | Spicy Queso Dip | Citrus Pickled Jalapeños | Pico de Gallo | Bacon | Cilantro Avocado Crema

    $18

  • Reef Cakes’ Spicy Queso Dip

    Our Own Spicy Queso | Tortilla Chips | Avocado Pico de Gallo

    $14

  • Tortilla Chips & Caribbean Salsa

    Caribbean Salsa | Tortilla Chips

    $12

Handhelds

  • Blackened Fish Tacos

    3 Tacos | Pico de Gallo | Cilantro Avocado Crema | Mexican Street Corn

    $MRKT

  • Happy Hippie

    Black Bean Veggie Burger | Toasted Brioche Bun | Lettuce | Tomato | Pickle | Onion | Boar’s Head Orange Blossom Honey Goat Cheese | Side of Asian Red Cabbage Slaw

    $16

  • Salmon Cake Banh Mi

    Asian-Style Salmon Reef Cakes | Toasted Hoagie | Pickled Carrots & Cucumbers | Cilantro | Thai Chili Mayo | Spring Mix Side Salad

    $23

  • SBLAT

    Blackened Salmon Filet | Open-Faced Hoagie | Applewood Smoked Bacon | Lettuce | Cilantro Avocado Crema | Tomato | Side of Quinoa Salad

    $27

  • The Old Greg

    Half Pound Fresh-Ground Beef Burger* | Toasted Brioche Bun | Roasted Red Peppers and Red Onions | Tomato | Lettuce | Jalapeños | Boar’s Head Smoked Gouda | Side of Tortilla Chips

    $22

  • The Florida Roll

    Reef Cakes’ Version of a Maine Lobster Roll but with Shrimp | Toasted Buns | Side of Asian Red Cabbage Slaw

    $22

  • Garden Grouper

    Jamaican Jerk Grouper Reef Cakes | Toasted Hoagie | Lettuce | Red Onion | Jerk Sauce | Quinoa Salad | Spring Mix Side Salad

    $39

  • Da Bomb

    Cajun Snapper and Shrimp Reef Cake | Toasted Brioche Bun | Remoulade Sauce | Roasted Red Peppers | Lettuce | Red Onion | Side of Cilantro Jasmine Rice

    $33

  • The Cod Father

    Breaded and Baked Cold Water Cod Loins | Toasted Hoagie | Lettuce | Tomato | Key Lime Tartar Sauce | Side of Asian Red Cabbage Slaw

    $16

  • New Orleans

    Blacked Gulf Shrimp Po’Boy | Toasted Hoagie | Lettuce | Tomato | Key Lime Tartar Sauce | Side of Chips and Caribbean Salsa

    $26

  • Bubba’s Shrimp Burger

    Shrimp Burger | Toasted Brioche Bun | Thai Chili Mayo | Side of Tri-Color Roasted Potatoes

    $17

Greens n' Bowls

All of our Greens are Organic

GREENS N' BOWLS

  • West Palm Beach

    Organic Arugula | Smoked Bacon | Avocado | Corn Medley | Hard-Boiled Egg | Roasted Red Peppers | Dressing of Choice

    $17

  • Kale Caesar*

    Romaine Lettuce | Kale | Parmesan | Roasted Brussels Sprouts | Quinoa | Croutons | Caesar* Dressing

    $13

  • Orange Ya Happy?

    Arugula | Baby Spinach | Quinoa | Orange Slices | Candied Walnuts | Roasted Red Peppers | Boar’s Head Orange Blossom Honey Goat Cheese | Dressing of Choice

    $16

  • Fusion Salad

    Baby Spinach | Romaine | Candied Walnuts | Dried Cherries | Heirloom Grape Tomatoes | Boar’s Head Orange Blossom Honey Goat Cheese | Dressing of Choice

    $12

  • Siesta Key Grain Bowl

    Quinoa | Barley | Farro | Romaine | Roasted Carrots | Cucumbers | Pickled Red Onions | Hard-Boiled Egg | Plantains | Apple Cider Vinaigrette

    $16

  • The Osprey Bowl

    Quinoa | Romaine | Baby Kale | Corn Medley | Red Onion | Cilantro | Citrus Pickled Jalapeños | Croutons | Dressing of Choice

    $15

PROTEINS

Served (grilled) or (blackened +$1)

  • Asian-Style Salmon Reef Cake

    $9

  • Maryland-Style Crab Reef Cake

    $MRKT

  • Cajun Snapper & Shrimp Reef Cake

    $11

  • Jamaican Jerk Grouper Reef Cake

    $11

  • Grilled Chicken Breast

    $8

  • Grilled Gulf Shrimp

    $10

  • Salmon Filet

    $18

  • Snapper Filet

    $24

  • Grouper Filet

    $24

  • House-Made Dressings

    Blackberry Vinaigrette

    Caesar*

    Raw Apple Cider Vinaigrette

    Buttermilk Ranch

Our Suggestions

  • Southside Village

    Cajun Snapper and Shrimp Reef Cakes | Gulf Grilled Shrimp | Scampi Sauce | Side of Roasted Brussels Sprouts

    $37

  • Jam ‘n Salmon

    Asian-Style Salmon Reef Cakes | Asian Red Cabbage Slaw | Arugula | Teriyaki Sauce | Grilled Pineapple | Side of Cold Sesame Noodles

    $26

  • Bob Marley

    Jamaican Jerk Grouper Reef Cakes | Caribbean Salsa | Jerk Sauce | Side of Tri-Colored Roasted Potatoes

    $32

  • Captain Crabs

    Maryland-Style Jumbo Lump Crab Reef Cakes | Corn Medley | Key Lime Tartar Sauce | Spring Mix Side Salad

    $MRKT

  • Mystic Man

    Lime-Grilled Salmon Filet | Cilantro Avocado Crema | Side of Pineapple Coconut Jasmine Rice | Side of Sautéed Greens

    $29

  • WPC

    Maryland-Style Jumbo Lump Crab Reef Cakes | Tri-Colored Roasted Potatoes | Remoulade Sauce | Side of Sautéed Greens | Seasoned Corn on the Cob

    $MRKT

  • Cool Ruler

    Blacked Grouper Filet | Avocado | Pico de Gallo | Red Chili Sauce | Plantains | Side of Cilantro Jasmine Rice

    $44

  • Key West

    Blackened Red Snapper Filet | Scampi Sauce | Grilled Pineapple | Cilantro Jasmine Rice

    $39

  • Tuscany

    Bucatini Pasta | Scampi Sauce | Grilled Gulf Shrimp | Smoked Pork Belly | Toasted Crostini

    $25

CREATE YOUR OWN

1.Protein

  • Reef Cakes

    Asian-Style Salmon Reef Cakes $18

    Cajun Snapper & Shrimp Reef Cakes $22

    Jamaican Jerk Grouper Reef Cakes $22

    Maryland-Style Jumbo Lump Crab Reef Cakes

    $MRKT

  • Fish Filets

    Served grilled or blackened $1

    Salmon Filet $19

    Grouper Filet $25

    Red Snapper Filet $25

  • Beyond the Reef

    Grilled Chicken Breast $12

    Veggie Burger - Third pound house-made black bean veggie burger made with five garden vegetables $14

    Shrimp Burger $15

    Beef Burger* - Half pound fresh-ground beef burger* $16

  • Sliced Boar's Head Cheese

    Choice of White Cheddar, Pepper Jack, Smoked Gouda, American

2.BED

All Things on Hoagies & Brioche Buns Come with Lettuce, Tomato, Pickle, Onion

  • Cake Beds

    All of our Greens are Organic

    Arugula

    Baby Spinach

    Spring Mix

    Romaine Lettuce

    Baby Kale

    Toasted Brioche Bun

    Toasted Hoagie

    Lean & Mean - (No Bun, No Greens)

3.ENHANCERS

  • Red Onion

    $0.50

  • Tomato Slice

    $0.50

  • Jalapeños

    $0.50

  • Boar’s Head Dill Pickles

    $0.50

  • Heirloom Grape Tomatoes

    $1

  • Firecracker Sauce

    $2

  • Key Lime Tartar Sauce

    $2

  • Cocktail Sauce

    $2

  • Remoulade Sauce

    $2

  • Thai Chili Mayo

    $2

  • Jerk Sauce

    $2

  • Asian Red Cabbage Slaw

    $3

  • Teriyaki Sauce

    $3

  • Caribbean Salsa

    $3

  • Scampi Sauce

    $3

  • Cilantro Avocado Crema

    $3

  • Pico De Gallo

    $3

  • Corn Medley

    $4

  • House-Made Dressings

    Blackberry Vinaigrette

    Caesar*

    Raw Apple Cider Vinaigrette

    Buttermilk Ranch

4. Sides

  • Avocado Slices

    $3

  • Applewood Smoked Bacon

    $3

  • Chips and Caribbean Salsa

    $4

  • Grilled Pineapple

    $4

  • Spring Mix Side Salad

    $4

  • Roasted Tri-Colored Potatoes

    $4

  • Sauteed Greens

    $5

  • Caribbean Salsa

    $5

  • Cold Sesame Noodles

    $5

  • Pineapple Coconut Jasmine Rice

    $5

  • Asian Red Cabbage Slaw

    $5

  • Roasted Brussels Sprouts

    $5

  • Cilantro Jasmine Rice

    $5

  • Mexican Street Corn

    $5

  • Quinoa Salad

    $7

  • Grilled Gulf Shrimp

    $10

KIDS MENU

  • Fish Sticks

    Two Fish Sticks with a Side of Ranch and Your Choice of Apple Wedges, Carrot Sticks or Orange Slices

    $14

  • Burger* Buddies

    Two Burger* Sliders with a Side of Ranch and Your Choice of Apple Wedges, Carrot Sticks or Orange Slices

    $12

    Cheese $1

  • Chicky Chicks

    Grilled Chicken Breast with a Side of Ranch, Carrot Sticks, and Buttered Noodles

    $14

  • Junior Reef Cakes

    Asian-Style Salmon Reef Cakes with a Side of Ranch and Your Choice of Apple Wedges, Carrot Sticks or Orange Slices

    $14

  • The Camber

    Colby Jack and American Grilled Cheese with a Side of Ketchup and Your Choice of Apple Wedges, Carrot Sticks or Orange Slices

    $14

  • Add Roasted Potatoes

    $2

DESSERTS

  • Key Lime Pie

    $9

  • Bread Pudding (Flavor Varies Weekly)

    $12

Email Signup

Please check errors in the form above
Thank you for signing up for email updates!